Get the facts about the CPV Valley Energy Center ...

ENVIRONMENTAL MYTHS

The Facts: Natural gas is the cleanest burning fossil fuel in existence and significantly reduces CO2 emissions and particulate matter in the air as compared to coal fired power plants. The plant will meet the stringent limits set by the New York Department of Environmental Conservation for VOC, NOx, SO2, PM and formaldehyde to protect human health and environment.

The Facts: The project is not located in a “protected agricultural area” because no such designation exists within the town or state code. The property is zoned mixed commercial. Portions of the property were previously farmed and received an agricultural tax exemption, however, the property is not restricted to agricultural use.

The Facts: The site underwent a thorough endangered species review during the 4+ year State Environmental Quality Review Act (known as SEQRA) process. During that process, it was confirmed that there were no new endangered species found on the site. In fact, this claim was reviewed and subsequently rejected by the state supreme court.

The Facts:No trees were cut during a prohibited period.  To the contrary, trees were cut during the permitted period and no potential bat roosting trees were cut.

The Facts:There are no Native American burial grounds on the project site. During the SEQRA process, the site was evaluated for potential cultural resource of any archeological significance, and specifically for any Native American resources. This evaluation included consultation with the NY Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation, as well as local historians.  The results of the evaluation were made public for review and comment.  No Native American Burial Ground was found on the site.  

The Facts: CPV will be purchasing and using wastewater the City is currently discharging to the Wallkill River.  This is a demonstration of CPV’s commitment to environmentally responsible energy generation.  This wastewater will now have a productive industrial use and provide a new revenue stream for the City.  CPV is NOT permitted to make water withdrawals from the Wallkill River.  A cursory review of CPV SEQRA documents will show that CPV does not have a permit to withdraw water from the Wallkill.

The Facts: The water discharged back to the City of Middletown must meet the requirements of the Industrial Pretreatment Program established by the city.  This program ensures that the city only receives water of a quality that the wastewater system is designed to treat. In addition, the energy center is equipped with its own water purification system to provide the clean water mandated by the energy production process.


PROCESS AND PUBLIC INPUT MYTHS

The Facts: The NYSDEC was given the opportunity to be lead agency, but the town asserted its right to be lead agency to keep the process at the local level to ensure that local concerns and sensitivities were addressed during the SEQRA process. This was in compliance with state law that allows for the role of the lead agency to be assumed by local agencies, including a local planning board, or the DEC. As required under SEQRA, the DEC was designated as an involved agency and identified as such in the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS). The DEC received copies of all the EIS documents and provided comments during the SEQRA process.

The Facts:The Town Planning Board was intimately familiar with SEQRA and the obligations of acting as Lead Agency under SEQRA.  The Town Planning Board retained expertise in the required disciplines to conduct the SEQRA review, develop a Final Environmental Impact Statement and issue its Finding Statement.  Experts in the field of air quality, water, ecology, socio-economics, and visual were retained to approve the evaluation methods used to perform the study, as well as to review and approve the results of the various evaluations contained in the Environmental Impact Statement.  This process took over 4 years to conduct the volume of studies required and to apply scrutiny of the results and conclusions.

The Facts:The entire approval process of the Valley Energy Center has been an open and public process. There were over 100 public meetings, numerous public hearings, newspaper articles, and presentations from 2008 to 2015.  Input from the public was collected throughout the process. 

The Facts: FERC’s role is to review natural gas infrastructure related applications and ensure that only those projects that comply with agency regulations and conditions are approved.  As of November 2014, FERC had approved 451, or only 56%, of 803 applications for pipelines, compressor stations, gas storage, and liquefied natural gas export facilities dating back to 2006. 


NECESSITY MYTHS

The Facts: Project development was started well before the New Capacity Zone process began and was supported by market dynamics that signaled the need for a new power generation resource.  The New Capacity Zone was created to address issues regarding system reliability in, and power deliverability to, the Lower Hudson Valley zone due to the limitations of the transmission system and the needs that arose after several generators in the lower Hudson Valley discontinued service, specifically the Danskammer and Bowline power stations. Once the CPV Valley Energy Center comes online, the markets will adjust to the additional capacity within the zone, to the benefit of consumers. This is how a market is supposed to work; supply and demand dictate market activity.  The capacity zone has also spurred other activity including the Energy Highway and a number of other generation resources that are currently evaluating their entry either through repowering or new construction. 

The Facts: Indian Point’s capacity factor, i.e. the percentage of time it runs, for the past 3 years has been over 95% and over 93% for the past 7 years. Of that output, Indian Point is under contract to supply 50% to Con Edison, which serves New York.  Given those contracts, the loss of Indian Point will have a direct impact on the reliability of New York’s electric system.

The Facts:Any electricity generated by CPV will be delivered to the NY electric system.  Electricity will flow to serve the nearest connected load.  The electricity from this facility can be used locally or regionally depending on the system operating conditions and demand at any given moment.  To the extent the local load requires electricity to meet its demand, the CPV generated electricity can be used locally.  To the extent the local load is being met, but there is need for electricity elsewhere on the system, the electricity can be used to meet that load.  


ECONOMIC MYTHS

The Facts:There are no state tax subsidies for this project. The investment to build this plant is borne completely by CPV and its partners. The taxpayers will not make any payments to the project.  The project receives its revenue from producing and selling electricity into the market, where it is purchased by retailers for sale to customers. 




CPV Valley Energy Center

Environmental Technologies



CPV Valley Energy Center

Economic Benefits



Previous
Next

Hudson Valley Building and Construction Trades Council

"On behalf of our membership, which consists of 28 local trade unions and over 10,000 members, we strongly support the CPV Valley Energy Center project. Since this project was first announced, more than five years ago, we have worked closely with CPV and watched them work closely with local and regional communities to meet the needs of everyone involved. I really can’t say enough about their dedication to this being a model project."

- L. Todd Diorio, President Hudson Valley Building and Construction Trades Council

Advanced Testing

"Efficiency is ever-increasing through technological advances, however our usage of available energy continues to increase and we must be willing to upgrade our energy infrastructure to meet future demand. CPV's project is very timely as Indian Point's current license to operate is being considered for renewal. If not renewed New York could experience a major energy shortage and this project can help mitigate that."

James P. Smith, Jr.,
President, Advanced Testing

Orange County Partnership

Over the past five years CPV Valley Energy has, through a concerted effort to keep the public informed with open meetings, newsletters and an informational website, developed an unprecedented level of public support for its clean, natural gas powered electric generating facility. Undoubtedly, this project will foster an economic impact that will resonate well beyond Orange County and the lower Hudson Valley. Its location, which backs up against a major interstate highway and fronts on a highly traveled state road, is within the Priority Growth Corridor.

Maureen Halahan
President & CEO Orange County Partnership

Orange County Citizens Foundation

"According to both the Orange County Comprehensive Plan and the Town of Wawayanda's own planning policy, the area selected for the project is designated for commercial development. The project is a good use of the land."

Nancy Proyect
President, Orange County Citizens Foundation

Hudson Valley Pattern for Progress

"Hudson Valley Pattern for Progress is a regional planning and policy organization dedicated to enhancing quality of life by promoting a balance between economic development and environmental protection. To that point, we find the integration of a gas-fired facility to be a strong compromise in addressing and preserving those two goals. The people of this region, as always, require that their energy needs be met through thoughtful, environmentally conscious and economically prudent means and the CPV project meets those objectives."

Jonathan Drapkin
President and CEO Hudson Valley Pattern for Progress

Orange County Chamber of Commerce

"Since the CPV team first introduced this project almost five years ago, they have built an unprecedented level of local support. This has occurred not by chance, but because CPV has gone to great lengths to work with local and regional communities to meet the needs of everyone involved. They have held scores of meetings with community members to educate everyone involved and to receive feedback on how to create a better project. This intensive outreach effort is likely the reason that this major power project enjoys such strong local support."

John A. Ambrosio, Ed.D.,
President Orange County Chamber of Commerce

Alliance for Balanced Growth

"As Co-Chairmen of the Alliance for Balanced Growth, we enthusiastically support CPV Valley Energy Center's site plan permit application before the Town of Wawayanda Planning Board."

John Lavelle &
Dominic Cordisco
Co-Chairs, Alliance for Balanced Growth

Local Resident

The CPV Valley Energy Center will have a significant positive impact for everyone in our community. The construction of this project will employ hundreds of workers in need of jobs and, once opened, the Energy Center will be a significant employer. The CPV Valley Energy Center will become a major tax payer, especially important to our school system which has been hit hard in recent years by budget cuts."

Jean Halahan
Local Resident

City of Middletown

"The CPV Valley Energy Center is precisely the type of facility that achieves the goals and objectives established by the Governor for his Energy Highway program. The addition of this project to the state's fleet of generation will enhance the overall reliability of New York's electric system not only due to its location in the Lower Hudson Valley, but also due to the plant's dual fuel capability."

Joseph M. DeStefano, Mayor
City of Middletown